Great Music Teaching Framework
Developed by Carnegie Hall’s Weill Music Institute
Great teaching starts with a commitment to great learning. Great teachers build expansive learning environments for their students and seek learning opportunities for themselves that are ambitious, open-ended, playful, and curious. These values align with the core interests of Carnegie Hall’s Weill Music Institute (WMI) in supporting artistry, community, and equity in all of its music making and music learning in schools and community settings, and with pre-professional musicians.
Within WMI, these values also guide how we frame our ongoing conversation about what great music teaching looks like. Regardless of the environment, great teachers artfully manage a balancing act between modeling the building blocks of the artistic process and inspiring young musicians to be creative and make music an important part of their lives.
How can music teachers engage with this framework?
We believe that all educators and artists constantly reflect on who they are within the arts and education. This search for identity goes in different directions and evolves over time. This framework serves as a starting point for music teachers to explore many possibilities as they shape their identities. Throughout this process, teachers and artists are encouraged to be flexible, collaborative, and compassionate about their own practices.
This framework focuses mainly on teachers and artists, with the understanding that their development will make a great impact on their students. It also provides insight into how great music teachers can build toward the parts of their teaching identities they want to grow.
Great music teachers believe in a holistic approach to their work, and engage with most, if not all, of the impulses outlined in this framework on a daily basis. Whether they embody these impulses already or are looking to them to provide a path toward future learning, great music teachers always reflect on how they can continue to learn and grow.
Great Music Teachers ...
- are musicians who model their artistry in everything they do
- experiment with new musical ideas and approaches alongside their students
- explore their own histories and identify the strengths of their artistry
- seek to expand their own artistic horizons in order to better identify with the learning process
- select meaningful and rich repertoire, and share their enthusiasm with their students
- interrogate the activities they organize for their students, constantly asking questions about whether students could get more from their teaching
- set strong developmental goals for learning for both their students and themselves
- ask questions that spark conversations while requiring comfort with ambiguity
- keep all learning grounded in a broad range of personal experiences
- mark their own learning and development through research and collaboration
- empower students to observe evidence of their own growth
- seek out opportunities to be inspired, musically or otherwise, and reflect on the impact of their experiences
- give students the opportunity to love their own work and growth
- encourage students to embrace their personal expression and musical voices
- create learning environments that are responsive to the needs of students in the context of their communities’ strengths and challenges
- meet students where they are in their development while acknowledging and celebrating the variety of learning abilities
- create an environment where students can build their emotional lives alongside their artistry
- model listening as a way to connect to other people and their cultures
- emphasize expression and choice making when working with existing repertoire
- see the composition of new music as a central music-learning activity
- use students’ ears to improvise on and venture away from written music
- explore a range of approaches for capturing, notating, and recording original ideas
- encourage students to embrace their ability to tell their own stories
- empower students to design and lead their own musical learning
- provide opportunities for students to share their work, practice, and process with their community